News Chicago Business, Info & Events
Chicago Italian beef scene just got the ultimate review treatment. Jeff Mauro, the Sandwich King himself, has released his highly anticipated compilation video featuring the best Italian beefs in the Chicago area — and it is must-watch content for anyone who takes their sandwiches seriously.
What is in the Compilation?
The video rounds up reviews from Jeff Mauro Sandwich Kingdom series, putting five iconic Chicago-area spots head-to-head using his signature “Chicago Star Points” rating system (out of 6):
- Johnnie Beef — Elmwood Park, IL
- Scatchell Beef & Pizza — Cicero, IL
- Pete Red Hots
- Mr. Beef — with Sylvia Perez
- Teddy Red Hots — with Mario Turano
The Chicago Italian Beef Standard
If you are not familiar with the Chicago Italian beef, picture this: thin-sliced roast beef, piled high on a crusty Italian roll, swimming in gravy, and topped with spicy giardiniera. It is messy, it is dripping, and it is one of the most beloved sandwiches in the city.
What sets Jeff Mauro apart is his systematic approach to rating — the “Chicago Star Points” system gives each spot a fair, reproducible score that lets you compare across locations. Many of his reviews land in the high 5-star range, which tells you just how strong the Chicago Italian beef game is.
About Jeff Mauro (The Sandwich King)
Jeff Mauro became known as the “Sandwich King” through his Food Network shows and YouTube content, where he explores sandwiches of all kinds with a Chicago focus. His channel @jeffmaurosandwichkingdom is the go-to resource for anyone wanting to navigate Chicago sometimes confusing sandwich landscape with an expert guide.
Why This Matters for Chicago Food Lovers
Chicago Italian beef is one of those foods that locals take very seriously — and for good reason. The combination of quality roast beef, proper gravy preparation, the right roll, and the perfect amount of giardiniera is harder to nail than it looks. This compilation is essentially a curated shortlist of where to get the best version of this Chicago classic.
Whether you are a Chicago native looking to validate your current favorite spot or a visitor planning your food itinerary, this Sandwich Kingdom compilation is the resource you did not know you needed.
Have a favorite Italian beef spot in Chicago? Let us know in the comments — we are always looking for the next great beef.