Squats vs. Walking: The Surprising Winner for Taming Blood Sugar Spikes

We’ve all heard it – sitting is the new smoking. For many of us, long hours glued to a desk are an inescapable reality, leading to a host of health concerns, including worrying spikes in blood sugar after meals. But what if the solution to these post-meal surges was simpler than we thought, and even better, could be squeezed into your workday without breaking a sweat (or even changing into gym clothes)?

Two recent studies, highlighted in a fascinating Earth.com article by Jordan Joseph, have shed light on a surprising victor in the battle against post-meal glucose spikes: squats.

The Showdown: Squats vs. Mini-Walks vs. Long Walks

Researchers at Zhejiang University, led by lead author Ying Gao, put different movement strategies to the test with 18 young men. The goal? To see which method best reduced after-meal blood sugar surges. The four single-day trials included:

  1. Long, uninterrupted sitting
  2. A 30-minute stroll
  3. Three-minute mini-walks every 45 minutes
  4. Ten fast body-weight squats every 45 minutes

The results were truly eye-opening. Both the ten fast squats and the frequent three-minute mini-walks slashed postprandial sugar spikes by a remarkable 21 percent compared to continuous sitting.

What’s even more surprising? This “sugar-flattening effect” almost doubled the benefit of the lone, 30-minute walk. This indicates a crucial insight: when it comes to blood sugar management, muscle engagement and timing seem to matter more than total steps or extended exercise sessions. The energy burned across all conditions was matched, meaning it wasn’t simply about extra calorie loss.

Why Squats Take the Crown

So, why did squats outperform a longer walk? It comes down to muscle activation. Squatting heavily recruits the quadriceps and glutes – some of the largest glycogen reservoirs in your body. The study found a direct correlation between higher averaged electromyogram (aEMG) amplitude in these large muscles and lower blood sugar swings. More muscle fibers contracting simultaneously appear to pull more sugar out of circulation.

Repeatedly engaging these large muscles during the workday, even briefly, helps to deplete their glycogen stores. This sets the stage for later insulin-assisted refilling, a cycle that can effectively dampen glucose peaks in subsequent meals.

The Walking Paradox and Lasting Effects

While squats emerged as the definitive winner, the three-minute strolls every 45 minutes also performed impressively. This suggests that even small, frequent bursts of movement can “wake up” leg muscles and keep sugar disposal lines open throughout the day. The “walking paradox” highlights that short, frequent nudges throughout the day are more effective than one heroic push.

The benefits of these “movement snacks” extend beyond immediate glucose reduction. As physiologist Gregory Cartee noted, “Enhanced skeletal muscle and whole body insulin sensitivity can persist for between 24 and 48 hours after one exercise session.” This means that each squat or mini-walk break can lead to prolonged metabolic calm. Because squats engage more muscle fibers, they may even extend this window further. The compounding effect over hundreds of workdays could be substantial.

Incorporating “Movement Snacks” into Your Day

The good news is, integrating these powerful movements into your daily routine is incredibly simple:

  • Ten deep squats take roughly 20 seconds and require no equipment. Set a 45-minute timer, stand up, perform ten squats, and then sit back down.
  • If squats aren’t feasible due to knee pain or space constraints, a three-minute hallway march delivers nearly the same payoff.

The key takeaway is to break up sitting time often and push large muscles hard enough to feel them work. Pairing these “movement snacks” with balanced meals can further amplify their benefits, especially for those managing carbohydrate intake. Remember, consistency beats intensity.

While the study focused on healthy young men, future research will explore how these findings apply to older adults, women, and individuals with diabetes. However, the evidence strongly suggests that simple, frequent movement breaks are a powerful tool in managing blood sugar and promoting long-term metabolic health.

So, the next time you feel stuck at your desk, consider setting a timer. A few quick squats or a short stroll might be the best prescription for your blood sugar.

The full study is published in the Scandinavian Journal of Medicine & Science in Sports.